If you live in San Antonio or have driven through the city, you know that potholes are a big problem on many roads. These pesky craters can range from small divots to massive crevices that can seriously damage your vehicle if you’re not careful. Blown tires, bent rims, suspension issues, and even accidents can result from hitting a bad pothole.

As a major city and one of the fastest-growing metros in the country, San Antonio has struggled to keep up with road maintenance and repairs amidst booming population growth and sprawl. While the city has recently committed more funds to improving streets, potholes remain a major headache for drivers.

So, what happens if a pothole on a San Antonio road damages your car? Can you get compensated by the city or sue for repairs and other costs? The answer depends on the specific circumstances, but you may have legal options to pursue damages. To find out if you have a claim, contact a San Antonio car accident attorney near you today.

Click for free case review

When the City May Be Liable for Pothole Damage

Under Texas law, municipalities like the City of San Antonio generally enjoy sovereign immunity, protecting it from lawsuits except under specific circumstances. This legal doctrine shields government entities from the constant threat of litigation, which can hinder their ability to effectively serve the public. However, the Texas Tort Claims Act provides a limited waiver of sovereign immunity in certain situations where the negligence of a government entity causes property damage, injuries, or even death.

Regarding pothole damage, the key factor in determining whether the city can be held liable is whether it had prior knowledge of the hazard and failed to address it within a reasonable timeframe. In other words, if the city knew about the pothole and had sufficient time to repair it before your incident occurred but did not do so, you may have grounds for a claim.

However, proving that the city had prior knowledge and ample time to fix the pothole can be challenging. To build a strong case, gather as much evidence as possible when the damage occurs. This starts with thoroughly documenting the scene of the incident. Take multiple clear photos of the pothole from different angles, capturing its size, depth, and location within the road. If there are any distinctive landmarks, street signs, or buildings nearby, include them in your photos to help establish the exact location.

Next, make note of the date, time, and weather conditions when the incident occurred. This information can be relevant in determining how long the pothole may have existed and whether the city had a reasonable opportunity to address it based on weather and road crew availability.

After documenting the scene:

  • Turn your attention to your vehicle.
  • Take photos of the damage from different angles, capturing any dents, scrapes, or other visible signs of impact.
  • Take these photos before moving your vehicle from where the damage occurred.

In addition to photographic evidence, filing a police report is important for creating an official incident record. Call the non-emergency police line and request that an officer come to the scene to document what happened. Be sure to get a copy of this report for your records, as it can serve as valuable evidence in your claim.

If any witnesses saw you hit the pothole, ask for their contact information and see if they’d be willing to provide a statement about what they observed. Eyewitness accounts can help corroborate your version of events and strengthen your case.

Finally, keep records of any repairs and associated expenses you incur due to the pothole damage. This includes towing fees, mechanic bills, rental car costs, and receipts for replacement parts. These documents will be essential in proving the extent of your damages and the financial impact the incident has had on you.

When you’re ready to file your claim with the city,  your San Antonio car accident lawyer will compile this documentation and evidence into a comprehensive packet. You should also include a detailed explanation of what happened, the extent of the damages you suffered, and any relevant evidence you’ve gathered. Once your attorney submits your claim, the city will investigate whether it believes it is liable for your damages.

If the city denies your claim, don’t be discouraged. If you believe you have a strong case, you still have the option to escalate the matter by filing a lawsuit. However, it’s important to understand that taking legal action against a government entity can be challenging. You must follow strict deadlines and procedural requirements, and the city will likely mount a vigorous defense.

To enhance your chances of success, consult with a San Antonio car accident attorney who handles pothole damage claims against municipalities. A lawyer can assess the strength of your case, advise you on the best course of action, and guide you through the legal process.

Remember, while the city is responsible for maintaining safe roads for drivers, it is not automatically liable for every pothole-related incident. The key is proving that it was negligent in addressing a known hazard. By gathering strong evidence and working with a knowledgeable San Antonio car accident lawyer, you can greatly improve your chances of holding the city accountable and recovering the compensation you deserve for your damages.

Challenges of Suing the City for Pothole Damage

While you can take legal action against the City of San Antonio for pothole-related vehicle damage, the journey to a successful outcome often involves numerous challenges and obstacles. Suing a government entity is rarely easy, and several factors can make winning a case against the city particularly difficult.

Road workers in orange safety gear repairing a pothole on a rural road with equipment.

One of the primary challenges in pursuing a pothole damage claim is the burden of proof. To hold the city liable, you must demonstrate that they were negligent in addressing the pothole hazard within a reasonable timeframe. This means showing that the city had prior knowledge of the problem and failed to take appropriate action to fix it despite having the opportunity to do so.

However, proving negligence can be a tricky proposition. The City of San Antonio maintains a vast network of roads totaling over 6,400 miles. With such an extensive area and a limited repair budget, the city will likely argue that it must first prioritize addressing the most severe and high-traffic problems. They may claim that, given the sheer number of potholes that develop across the city, it’s simply not feasible to fix every single one immediately.

To counter this defense, you must present compelling evidence that the specific pothole that caused your damage was a known hazard that the city had ample time and resources to address. This can include records of prior complaints or 311 reports about the pothole, testimony from witnesses who can attest to how long it had existed, or evidence that the pothole was in a high-priority area that should have received top focus for repairs.

Another significant challenge in suing the city is the potential cap on damages. Under the Texas Tort Claims Act, there is a limit of $250,000 on the compensation you can receive from a municipality for property damage claims. This means that even if you have a strong case and can prove the city was entirely at fault, the maximum amount you can recover is $250,000.

Depending on the extent of your vehicle damage and associated expenses, this cap may or may not be sufficient to fully cover your losses. If your damages exceed this amount, you will have to absorb the additional costs yourself, regardless of the strength of your case.

Furthermore, if your pothole damage claim goes to court, you can expect the city to mount a defense. One common tactic they may use is shifting some or all of the blame onto you as the driver. They may argue that you were fully or partially at fault for the incident, citing factors like excessive speed, distracted driving, or failure to heed warning signs about road hazards.

Another procedural hurdle in suing the city is the strict timeline for taking action. If you plan to file a lawsuit against a government entity in Texas, you must first submit a formal notice of claim within just six months of the date of the incident. This notice must include specific details about what happened, the extent of your damages, and the compensation you seek.

If the city denies your initial claim, you have a limited window to file a court lawsuit. Missing either of these key deadlines can result in losing your right to pursue a case entirely, even if you have strong evidence to support your claim.

Given these significant challenges and potential roadblocks, it’s highly advisable to consult with a knowledgeable attorney as soon as possible if you believe you have a viable pothole damage claim against the City of San Antonio. They can weigh the potential risks and rewards of pursuing legal action and develop a strategic approach to maximize your chances of securing a favorable outcome.

An attorney can also provide valuable guidance on the strength of your case and the likelihood of success, given the specific circumstances involved. They can evaluate the potential risks and rewards of pursuing legal action and develop a strategic approach to maximize your chances of securing a favorable outcome.

Sometimes, your lawyer can negotiate a settlement with the city without needing a lengthy court battle. However, if litigation does become necessary, having a skilled legal advocate in your corner can make all the difference in presenting a persuasive case and fighting for the full compensation you deserve.

Steps to Take If Your Vehicle Is Damaged

If you do hit a pothole and sustain vehicle damage while driving in San Antonio, take the following steps to protect yourself and preserve your rights:

  • Safely pull over and turn on your hazard lights. Call for emergency assistance if needed.
  • Take photos of the pothole, nearby signs or landmarks, and all vehicle damage.
  • Look for witnesses and get their contact information if they are willing to provide a statement.
  • File a police report by calling the non-emergency number and requesting an officer on the scene. The police report creates an official record of the incident.
  • If your car is undrivable, request a tow truck. Get an estimate and complete the repairs, saving all invoices and receipts.
  • Notify your auto insurance company of the incident. Some comprehensive coverage policies may pay for pothole damage.
  • File a claim with the City of San Antonio’s Claims Office by submitting the required forms and attaching relevant evidence. The city has 45 days to investigate and decide on your claim.
  • If authorities reject your claim, contact a knowledgeable San Antonio car crash lawyer to discuss your options and assess the likelihood of success in a lawsuit. Your ability to sue may depend on the road’s jurisdiction, notice issues, sovereign immunity, and more.

Reach Out Today for a Free Consultation with a San Antonio Car Accident Lawyer

Potholes may seem like another annoying reality of driving in San Antonio, but they can cause real damage, leading to costly vehicle repairs and accidents. If the city’s negligence in maintaining roads leads to pothole damage, you can file a claim or sue to seek compensation.

However, proving the city is truly at fault and winning your case can be difficult. Document as much evidence as possible, file your claim promptly and prepare to tackle challenges securing payment from the city.

Consulting with an experienced car accident attorney is the best way to understand your rights and get advice on the strength of your claim. A lawyer can build the strongest case for you in a dispute with the city. If you’ve been the victim of pothole damage on San Antonio roads, don’t assume you have to pay out of pocket for repairs. Contact a knowledgeable personal injury lawyer in San Antonio today to discuss your situation and learn what legal options you may have to hold the city accountable.

Click for free case review