Who is at Fault for a T-bone Accident?

April 19, 2025 | By Ted R. Lorenz
Who is at Fault for a T-bone Accident?

T-bone accidents can be frightening and often leave drivers feeling overwhelmed and confused. In these collisions, one vehicle strikes the side of another, typically at an intersection. Determining who is at fault for a T-bone accident is complex and often requires carefully analyzing the facts and circumstances surrounding the collision. Factors such as traffic laws, right of way, and driver behavior all play a role in determining liability.

If you have been in a T-bone accident, it is important to seek legal help to protect your rights and ensure you receive the compensation you deserve. Contact a car accident attorney to discuss your situation and take appropriate legal action.

CLICK FOR FREE CASE REVIEW

What is a T-Bone Car Accident?

T-bone car accident with visible side impact damage on silver SUV and front-end damage on black sedan under clear blue sky.

A T-bone car accident, also known as a side-impact or broadside collision, occurs when one vehicle crashes into the side of another car at a perpendicular angle, forming a "T" shape. These accidents frequently occur at intersections but can also happen in parking lots or when drivers fail to yield the right of way. The impact from a T-bone accident can result in severe injuries or even fatalities, as the side of a vehicle offers less protection compared to the front or rear.

Various factors can cause T-bone accidents, such as distracted driving, speeding, running a red light or stop sign, failing to yield, or driving under the influence. Determining fault in a T-bone accident requires carefully examining the evidence and understanding the applicable traffic laws.

T-bone car accidents are dangerous crashes because the front of one vehicle strikes the broad side of another. For the front car, there is an impact that is similar to a head-on collision. If the other motorist gets hit on the driver’s side of the vehicle, they may also suffer serious injuries. The same applies to passengers sitting on the side where impact occurs. Thus, it is not surprising that the fatality rate in t-bone accidents is higher than in other types of motor vehicle crashes.

Who Is To Blame for a T-Bone Car Accident

Assigning blame in a T-bone car accident depends on several factors. The driver who failed to yield the right of way or violated traffic laws is often at fault. The law considers failure to follow traffic laws negligence since a reasonable driver yields the right of way when the law requires it.

However, each case is unique, and multiple parties can share liability. Insurance companies may try to find a way to blame you for the accident, even when the other driver was the one who ran the stop sign or red light. They may claim that you were speeding, distracted, or had a way to avoid the accident when their driver ran a red light or stop sign. If that is the case, you may find that the insurance company reduces your compensation or does not pay you at all.

Determining fault in a T-bone car accident requires a thorough investigation, including gathering evidence, eyewitness testimonies, and accident reconstruction. It is important to consult a qualified attorney with experience with car accident law to protect your legal rights.

Forms of Evidence in a T-Bone Car Accident

To determine liability in a T-bone car accident, various forms of evidence are key in establishing fault.

Here are some key types of evidence that can help build a strong case:

  • Police report: The police report the officer creates at the accident scene provides essential details about the collision, including statements from the involved parties, witnesses, and any applicable citations. You can use the police report when filing an insurance claim but not as evidence at trial since the court considers it hearsay. Insurance companies often defer to what the officer says about the accident, even if they did not see the crash itself.
  • Pictures of the accident scene: These pictures can tell a lot about the angle of the crash. Depending on the vehicle damage involved in the crash, it may be possible to learn which driver was at fault for the accident. However, it may have been difficult for you to take pictures yourself since you were dealing with physical injuries at the accident scene.
  • Eyewitness testimonies: Statements from eyewitnesses who observed the accident can provide valuable insights into how the collision occurred and who is at fault. This form of evidence is often the most persuasive since third-party witnesses have no financial motivation for the story they tell.
  • Video surveillance: If the accident occurred at an intersection or in an area with video surveillance, obtaining footage from nearby cameras can provide objective evidence of the events leading up to the collision.
  • Accident reconstruction: A professional accident reconstruction expert can analyze factors such as vehicle damage, skid marks, and road conditions to recreate the sequence of events and determine fault. This documentation is helpful to your attorney if they need physical evidence to prove negligence.

Car accident evidence can disappear in a hurry. Sometimes, you may only have days to gather the available evidence. It may not be possible for you to perform this task on your own, making it even more critical that you hire a car accident attorney as soon as possible after the crash. Once the car accident evidence is gone to you, it is lost forever, and it may become more challenging to prove your case. Promptly contacting a car accident lawyer can give you a better chance to qualify for financial compensation.

What Is a Truth Contest?

In some T-bone car accident cases, the involved parties may present conflicting accounts of how the collision occurred. The other driver may fear being liable for the accident and will make up their own story, claiming that you were the one who failed to yield the right of way. When two parties tell a completely different story, it is known as a “truth contest.” You need to find a way to break the logjam. Otherwise, you may not qualify for financial compensation. You need evidence showing what the driver did to contradict their story.

CLICK FOR FREE CASE REVIEW

What Happens if the Other Driver Is Telling a Different Story After a T-Bone Car Accident?

If the other driver involved in the T-bone car accident is telling a different story, it is important not to panic or lose hope. Conflicting accounts are common in accident cases, and resolving such disputes is part of the legal process.

Here are the steps to take:

  • Consult with an attorney: Contact a car accident attorney as soon as possible to discuss your situation. They can guide you through the legal process and help protect your rights.
  • Gather evidence: Collect evidence that supports your version of the events, such as photographs, witness statements, and any applicable documentation.
  • Obtain witness statements: If there were witnesses to the accident, reach out to them and ask if they are willing to provide a statement or testify on your behalf.
  • Accident reconstruction: Consider hiring an accident reconstruction expert to analyze the evidence and objectively assess how the collision occurred.
  • Present your case: Your attorney will present evidence, statements, and expert analysis to support your version of events and refute the other driver's claims.

While hiring an attorney is not a guarantee that you can prove fault, it can help you fight back when you hear a different story from the insurance company other than the one you know to be the truth.

Remember, having an attorney by your side is vital when handling a T-bone car accident dispute. They have experience with these situations and can protect your rights throughout the legal process.

You Can File a Car Accident Lawsuit

Insurance companies do not get the final say about which driver was liable for the accident. They have financial motivations in determining that their driver was not responsible for the accident because they want to avoid paying you. However, you have further legal remedies when the insurance company does not accept your story and denies your claim. You can even take additional legal steps when the insurance company is trying to blame you for the accident partially.

In any car accident case, you have the right to file a lawsuit against the responsible driver in court, and you can file one even if you have already tried to go through the insurance claims process. The advantage of filing a lawsuit in court is that you can continue to develop your case as the lawsuit progresses through the legal system. Your car accident lawyer can question the other driver under oath, both in a deposition and at a trial. Then, your car accident attorney can puncture the other driver’s story when there is a truth contest.

Ultimately, the jury will decide your case from the evidence they hear. The risk of going to a jury trial may mean that you end up with no compensation. However, the prospect of litigation may also frighten the insurance company into settling the case before it reaches a jury.

Why Do You Need a Lawyer Right After a T-Bone Car Accident?

Being in a T-bone car accident can have serious consequences, including physical injuries, emotional distress, and financial burdens.

Here is why you need to consult with a lawyer right after a T-bone car accident:

  • Legal guidance: An experienced car accident attorney can provide valuable advice and explain your rights based on the specific circumstances of your case.
  • Protection of your rights: Your attorney will work tirelessly to protect your rights and ensure you receive the compensation you deserve for your injuries, medical expenses, lost earnings, and other damages.
  • Evidence collection: A skilled attorney will promptly gather and preserve key evidence to support your case, including accident reports, witness statements, and expert analysis.
  • Negotiation with insurance companies: Insurance companies often try to minimize payouts or deny claims. Your attorney will handle all communication and negotiations with the insurance companies, ensuring they represent your best interests.
  • Pursuit of legal action: If you cannot reach a fair settlement with the insurance company, your attorney will prepare to take your case to court and fight for your rights before a judge or jury.
  • Peace of mind: Dealing with the aftermath of a T-bone car accident can be overwhelming. Having a knowledgeable attorney on your side will give you peace of mind, knowing that a professional will handle your legal matters with your best interests at heart.

In any car accident case, you cannot delay hiring a lawyer to represent you. The need is even more significant in a t-bone accident case because of the potential for the drivers to tell two different stories and for the insurance company to try to blame you.

A Car Accident Attorney Costs You Nothing Out of Pocket

Car accident lawyers understand that accidents can cause a significant financial burden on victims. That is why most car accident lawyers offer their services on a contingency fee basis, meaning they do not get paid upfront, and their fees are contingent on winning your case. You will not owe your attorney anything if they do not win your case.

By offering their services on a contingency fee basis, car accident lawyers can provide accessible and affordable legal representation to those who need it most. They take the risk of pursuing your case and invest their time and resources in building a strong case on your behalf. This payment structure ensures that you have access to experienced legal professionals without worrying about upfront costs.

Proving fault in a side-impact collision is challenging, often involving traffic laws, eyewitness testimony, and accident reconstruction. An experienced attorney can investigate the accident thoroughly, gather evidence, and determine liability. By identifying the party at fault, your attorney can negotiate with the insurance companies or represent you in court.

Hire a Car Accident Lawyer Now

Hiring an attorney after a T-bone accident is pivotal. They will handle the complex legal process, investigate the accident, determine fault, negotiate with insurance companies, and fight for your best interests. Your attorney will protect your rights and ensure you receive your deserved compensation. Do not hesitate to contact a trusted personal injury attorney to guide you through this challenging time.

CLICK FOR FREE CASE REVIEW

Ted R. Lorenz Author Image

Ted R. Lorenz

Founder & Attorney

Author's Bio